Vive pro review way more beautiful, way better—way too expensive

A cycle, that’s now moving into its second era today, with the debut of the new Vive Pro. Sporting a higher-res display, a redesigned headset and some thoughtful creature comforts, the Vive Pro is better is almost every single way. Unfortunately, for a device that was already hard to justify buying, Vive’s second-gen headset is even more expensive now too. But let’s skip over that for a minute and instead talk about what this sequel really offers.

The first thing you notice is the Vive Pro’s new cool blue plastic housing, which features two front-mounted stereoscopic cameras. But don’t get too excited by those, because developers haven’t actually made anything that takes advantage of them yet.

The real treat is actually around back, and comes in the form of a little dial that can be used to adjust the headset’s fit. Clockwise to tighten, counterclockwise to loosen. It’s a small change, but it has a big effect, because on the OG Vive, every time you needed to make an adjustment, you basically had to take the whole rig off.

The one challenge to all this is that the Vive Pro’s built-in headphones are closer to on-ear cans that just sit on your ears than closed-back over-the-ear headphones that surround them. That means unless your VR room is perfectly quiet, ambient noise is going to leak in from outside, which isn’t ideal. And because the Vive’s Pro’s headphones just kind of dangle next to your ears instead of getting pressed into your head, there’s not much you can do to improve them. Thankfully, if you are so inclined, the Vive Pro has a hidden USB-C port, which can be used with a headphone adapter, so that you can still use your own headphones if you want.

OK, enough about the outside, what are the Vive Pro’s new optics like to actually use? At first, I was actually a bit underwhelmed. Despite increasing the Vive Pro’s resolution by 78 percent to 2880 x 1600 (or 1440 x 1600 to each eye), the jump in sharpness isn’t as big as the difference between standard def and an HD TV. Pixels are smaller, but they are still visible to the naked eye, and you can also see some jaggy, aliased lines on many diagonal polygons so things don’t always look perfectly smooth—like sitting to close to a TV. But even so, the overall impact is big, because while subtle, the improved fidelity combined with the better audio makes it easier than ever before to ignore meatspace and focus on what’s playing out virtually in front of your eyes.

Currently, there’s no tag to differentiate between games made for the OG Vive or the new Pro, but there will be soon. Not that it matters because even the most stark, minimalist games like Superhot look better in Vive’s new headset, while 360 videos viewed in the Vive Video app seem more lifelike too. But the experience that really showed me how far the Vive Pro had come was when I used the Bigscreen app to recreate the view from my physical desktop monitors in VR. Text looks so much better, and soon, I found myself writing chunks of this review while still wearing the headset. Even when compared to Samsung’s Odyssey HMD, which has the same resolution, the Vive Pro is better thanks to its more precise motion tracking, 3D spatial audio, and wide SteamVR and Viveport VR app support.

The power of the Vive Pro is that it turns the thought of working in VR from a silly idea into one that’s actually quite exciting. And once I saw better looking text on regular websites in VR, I started appreciating those details even more in full-on VR apps. It’s the ability to recreate finer details that’s is going to define this second era of VR development. The big strokes were there, the Vive Pro is adding the polish.

But now, back to the question of price. On one hand, the Vive Pro is so good that I wouldn’t want anyone to try out the first-gen headsets now that this exists. In a vacuum, it just doesn’t make sense to go back. But as something that you can actually buy, compared to the $500 kit that includes a standard Vive, two controllers and two base stations, the $800 Vive Pro is a real hard sell. And that’s before you consider that the full price for first-time VR explorers is actually $1,100, because the Vive Pro doesn’t come with any of the system’s essential peripherals, like base stations or controllers.

There’s also one last thing that’s really bugging me. At CES 2018, I tried a Vive Pro paired with the upcoming Vive’s upcoming Wireless Adapter, and after experiencing the joy and freedom of not having a wire tying me down, there’s no going back. If Vive put both the new headset and the wireless adapter in the Pro’s box, $800 or even $1,000 would actually feel like a steal. Maybe I’m spoiled, but to me, this headset needs that extra bit of futuristic tech to really justify its price. But regardless of whether you buy it or not, the second phase of the grand VR experiment has arrived. Unfortunately, most folks may not hop on until phase three, when companies can figure out a way to put all this marvelous tech together and make it affordable.